Judge John Tomasello awarded Dexter to Dare because he purchased the animal and paid the veterinary bills. “Dogs are chairs; they’re furniture; they’re automobiles, they’re pensions,” Tomasello said. “They’re not kids.”

Houseman appealed the ruling. In March, the appeals court ruled Tomasello “should not have treated Dexter like another piece of furniture” and should have considered the subjective value.

Tomasello ruled in August that Dexter was joint property because the couple lived together and cared for him together, but he has yet to decide who will keep the dog. He has asked for additional information from attorneys.