Pets: Property or family?

Pets: Property or family?

A New Jersey judge must rule on the ownership of a pug after its owners break up
source-image
Aug 28, 2009
By dvm360.com staff

A custody battle over a 6-year-old pug in New Jersey could have far reaching consequences to the veterinary profession. When Eric Dare and Doreen Houseman broke up three years ago, they couldn’t agree on who would keep Dexter. They split custody for a while, but eventually that amicable relationship soured and they took the case to court.

Judge John Tomasello awarded Dexter to Dare because he purchased the animal and paid the veterinary bills. “Dogs are chairs; they’re furniture; they’re automobiles, they’re pensions,” Tomasello said. “They’re not kids.”

Houseman appealed the ruling. In March, the appeals court ruled Tomasello “should not have treated Dexter like another piece of furniture” and should have considered the subjective value.

Tomasello ruled in August that Dexter was joint property because the couple lived together and cared for him together, but he has yet to decide who will keep the dog. He has asked for additional information from attorneys.

Hot topics on dvm360

Follow dvm360 on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest

For quick updates and to touch base with the editors of dvm360, Veterinary Economics, Veterinary Medicine, and Firstline, and check us out on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest.

Sell veterinary clients on your service

But you don't have to have butler-style service to win new clients and keep existing clients happy.

Why veterinarians should be more like a Louisiana shoeshiner

If my veterinary clients feel half as good as I did after visiting the 'Michael Jordan of shoeshines,' I'll be thrilled.

Texts from your veterinary clinic cat

If your clinic cat had a cell phone and opposable thumbs, what would he or she text you?

Learning goodbye: Veterinarians fill a void by focusing on end of life care

Veterinarians dedicating their careers to hospice and euthansia medicine may be pioneering the profession's next specialty—at clients' request.