Pets: Property or family?

Pets: Property or family?

A New Jersey judge must rule on the ownership of a pug after its owners break up
source-image
Aug 28, 2009
By dvm360.com staff

A custody battle over a 6-year-old pug in New Jersey could have far reaching consequences to the veterinary profession. When Eric Dare and Doreen Houseman broke up three years ago, they couldn’t agree on who would keep Dexter. They split custody for a while, but eventually that amicable relationship soured and they took the case to court.

Judge John Tomasello awarded Dexter to Dare because he purchased the animal and paid the veterinary bills. “Dogs are chairs; they’re furniture; they’re automobiles, they’re pensions,” Tomasello said. “They’re not kids.”

Houseman appealed the ruling. In March, the appeals court ruled Tomasello “should not have treated Dexter like another piece of furniture” and should have considered the subjective value.

Tomasello ruled in August that Dexter was joint property because the couple lived together and cared for him together, but he has yet to decide who will keep the dog. He has asked for additional information from attorneys.

Hot topics on dvm360

Vetcetera: The complex topic of canine fear-related aggression

A guided tour of resources for addressing this popular and complicated subject, featuring advice from Dr. John Ciribassi.

Reality TV and the veterinarian: Discussing mainstream dog training advice with clients

Your clients may be getting behavior advice from cable TV. Get your opinion in the mix.

Blog: Election results pose obstacles for veterinary prescription law

Flip in U.S. Senate's majority may slow progress of Fairness to Pet Owners Act.

The war between shelters, veterinarians needs to end

Despite practitioners’ legitimate gripes, they’re hurting themselves.

7 steps to a better relationship between veterinarians and rescue groups

A DVM in the city shares his advice to veterinary practices for working with rescues.